The Band Reparations Class Action

Gottfriedson v. His Majesty the King in Right of Canada
(Court File No. T1542-12)

The Band Reparations Class Action is a lawsuit against the Government of Canada. The lawsuit is about the collective harm suffered by Indigenous communities as a group as a result of Indian Residential Schools. The lawsuit says that the Government of Canada is responsible for damages to Indigenous communities caused by the Indian Residential School system, and in particular, the collective harm suffered by Indigenous communities due to the loss of language and culture because of Indian Residential Schools.

This lawsuit is not about harms suffered by individual survivors who attended Indian Residential Schools – instead it is about the collective harm suffered by Indigenous communities as a group as a result of Indian Residential Schools.

This lawsuit was brought by representative plaintiff First Nations Tk’emlúps te Secwépemc and shíshálh Nation, with the support of the Grand Council of the Crees (Eeyou Istchee).

Band Class Members

325 Bands are part of the lawsuit; click here to see the full list of class members. In order to participate in the lawsuit, Bands were required to “opt-in” or “join” the lawsuit by the extended June 30, 2022 opt-in deadline. The opt-in period is now closed, and it is no longer possible to join the lawsuit.

The First Nations that are part of the lawsuit are:

Settlement

A settlement agreement has been reached between the Representative Plaintiff Bands and the Government of Canada, which fully and finally resolves the Band Reparations Class Action.

The settlement agreement has been approved by the Federal Court as being fair, reasonable and in the best interests of the class.

Settlement Agreement

Full Settlement Agreement

The key terms of the settlement agreement are:

  • The government of Canada will make a payment of $2.8 billion (the “Fund”) to a Trust/Not-For-Profit to fully and finally resolve the Band Reparations Class Action.
  • The Trust/Not-For-Profit will be responsible for prudently investing the Fund, and for distributing the Fund to the 325 class members to support the Four Pillar principles in accordance with the Disbursement Policy.
  • The Four Pillars are:
    • Revival and protection of Indigenous languages;
    • Revival and protection of Indigenous cultures;
    • Wellness for Indigenous communities and their members;
    • Promotion and protection of heritage.
  • The Disbursement Policy will include the following:
    • Planning funds: Each Band Class member will receive an initial one-time payment of $200,000 for the purposes of developing a plan to carry out one or more of the objectives and purposes of the Four Pillars;
    • Initial Kick-Start Funds: Upon receipt and review of a plan from a band, the Fund shall disburse the Initial Kick-Start Funds, which shall be equal to the Band’s proportionate share of $325 million, with 40% attributable for base rate, with the remaining 60% to be used to adjust for population. The base rate is an equal amount payable to each Band. The Board will determine an appropriate adjustment for remoteness for the Initial Kick-Start Funds, with any such funds required to account for remoteness being in addition to the $325 million;
    • Annual Entitlement: Each Band will receive a share of annual investment income that is available for distribution. That share will be equal to the Band’s proportionate share, adjusted for population and remoteness.
  • All monies that remain in the Fund after the payment of the Planning Funds and the Kick-Start Funds will be prudently invested by the Trust/Not-For-Profit in accordance with professional investment advice.
  • The Fund will operate for a period of 20 years.
  • For the 20 year life of the Fund, the Annual Entitlement payments will be made from the investment income earned from the Fund; the capital of the Fund will be maintained.
  • At the end of the 20 year life of the Fund, the remaining funds consisting of the capital of the Fund and any undisbursed investment income will be disbursed to the Class. Each Band’s share shall be equal to the Band’s proportionate share of the remaining funds.
  • The Trust/Not-For-Profit will be responsible for determining the Disbursement Policy, which will consist of a base rate, a population adjustment, and a remoteness adjustment. That formula will allocate 40% to base rate, and 60% to population and remoteness adjustments.
  • The Trust/Not-For-Profit will be governed by a board of nine Indigenous directors, eight of which will be selected through a process involving the Representative Plaintiff Bands, and, in the case of Regional Directors, the Class Members, and one of which will be chosen by Canada.
  • The Trust/Not-For-Profit will have regional representation.
  • In exchange for the benefits of the agreement, the Band Class members are deemed to agree to a release which will prevent them from bringing legal claims in future against Canada regarding the collective harms caused to them by the creation and operation of Indian Residential Schools. For greater clarity, this release does not relate to, and will not impact, any possible claims regarding children who died or disappeared while in attendance at Residential Schools.
  • Lawyers’ fees and expenses incurred over the course of the lawsuit will be paid by the Government of Canada and will not be deducted from the compensation paid to the Band Class. Canada has agreed to pay for all legal fees and expenses. These fees and expenses must be approved by the court, and will be the subject of a fee approval hearing, which will take place immediately after the settlement approval hearing.

Settlement Approval Hearing

The Federal Court heard the plaintiffs’ motion for settlement approval on February 27 and 28, 2023.

Each of the 325 First Nations that joined the lawsuit had the opportunity to make written and/or oral submissions to the court in response to the settlement.

On March 9, 2023, the judge approved the settlement and concluded that it is fair, reasonable, and in the best interests of the class.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Band Reparations Class Action about?

The Band Reparations Class Action is a lawsuit against the Government of Canada regarding the collective harm suffered by Indigenous communities due to the loss of language and culture that resulted from Indian Residential Schools.

This lawsuit is not about harms suffered by individual survivors who attended Indian Residential Schools – instead it is about the collective harm suffered by Indigenous communities as groups as a result of Indian Residential Schools.

How was this settlement achieved?

This lawsuit was brought by representative plaintiff First Nations Tk’emlúps te Secwépemc and shíshálh Nation, with the support of the Grand Council of the Crees (Eeyou Istchee). Tk’emlúps te Secwépemc, shíshálh Nation and the Grand Council of the crees directed the litigation and participated in settlement negotiations.

It was very important during negotiations to achieve a settlement that would give Indigenous people control over the programs and initiatives that would assist in repairing harms to their Bands’ languages and cultures. The result was a trust that would operate for a 20-year period to provide funding to the Band Class Members in accordance with the Four Pillar principles.

The Four Pillars are:

  • Revival and protection of Indigenous languages;
  • Revival and protection of Indigenous cultures;
  • Wellness for Indigenous communities and their members;
  • Promotion and protection of heritage.

The settlement agreement was approved by the Federal Court on March 9, 2023.

Are individual members of the Bands entitled to compensation from this settlement?

No. This settlement addresses the collective harm to languages and cultures suffered by each Band Class Member, as a collective, as a result of Indian Residential Schools. This settlement does not relate to harms suffered by individuals.

Which Bands are included in this settlement?

This is an “opt-in” class action. That means that the Court allowed this lawsuit to proceed as a class action on behalf of Band Class Members that chose to be a part of it. There are 325 Band Class Members that opted in to this class action. Click here to see a full list of Band Class Members.

My Band is not on the list. Is it too late for my Band to join?

Yes. Unfortunately the deadline to opt in to this class action has closed. There is no further right to opt in.

Bands that did not opt in to this class action are not bound by its release. Your Band should seek advice from a lawyer about what rights and remedies may be available.

Does this settlement affect the rights of my Band or its members with respect to harms caused by churches or religious orders?

No. Section 27.04 of the Settlement Agreement says that “this Settlement Agreement does not settle, compromise, release or limit in any way whatsoever any claim by the [Class Members] against any person other than Canada.” The release in the settlement “cannot be relied upon by any Third Party, including any religious organization that was involved in the creation and operation of Residential Schools.”

Does this settlement affect Aboriginal or Treaty rights?

Only claims related to the Residential School System are released by the settlement. Aboriginal and Treaty rights are otherwise not impacted.

Can the Government use this settlement to stop future claims relating to children who died or disappeared while attending an Indian Residential School?

No. The lawsuit does not relate to children who died or disappeared while attending Residential Schools. Claims concerning children who died or disappeared are specifically excluded (protected) from the release.

I still have questions.

Please direct any questions you have to [email protected]. Class Counsel would be happy to get you answers.

Class Counsel

Class Counsel in this lawsuit are:

Peter R. Grant
Peter Grant Law Corporation

John K. Phillips, K.C.
W. Cory Wanless
Jonathan Schachter
Flora Yu
Waddell Phillips Professional Corporation

Diane Soroka
Diane Soroka Avocate Inc.

Contact

Phone: 1-888-370-1045 (toll-free)
Fax: 416-477-1657
Email: [email protected]
Att’n: Band Reparations Class Action
36 Toronto Street, Suite 1120
Toronto, ON
M5C 2C5